ibclogo XVI International Botanical Congess


Abstract Number: 4103
Poster No. = 1246


THE HERBIVORY UNCERTAINTY PRINCIPLE: MEASURING HERBIVORY UNPREDICTABLY CHANGES ITS STRENGTH


James F. Cahill, Jr1, Jeffrey C. Castelli2 and Brenda B. Casper2, 1University of Delaware, Newark DE, 2Univ. of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA


Here we show that uncertainty applies not just in physics, but also in ecology. We tested whether measuring herbivory influenced the effects of herbivory for 8 species in an old-field. Half of the plants were touched weekly to simulate the handling necessary to take morphological measures, and the other 1/2 left undisturbed. After 8 weeks, 4 of 8 species showed a significant difference in mortality or leaf area damaged as a function of visitation. Handling affected three species positively and one negatively. This surprising result serves as a reminder that seemingly benign methods may have dramatic effects on experimental results. Since the effects of handling differs among species, field researchers must integrate this new form of uncertainty into their experimental designs.


HTML-Version made 7. July 1999 by Kurt Stüber